The Margin WarsStart a conversation
$$$

Nobody loses margin on the rate. You lose it in the line items nobody owns.

We find the line items eating your margin, rank them by basis points, and give each one an owner.

Plate IThe leak

Latest from the Wire

Open the research desk ↗

01

Where margin goes missing

Not one big number. A hundred small ones: downgrades, unchecked scheme fees, hidden FX, soft declines, lazy routing, avoidable cross-border fees. Together, they're the margin.

02

What we do about it

Specific moves: net revenue over TPV, merchant of record by flow, FX by corridor, local rails, loss-based PayFac pricing. Each shown for US, UK/EU, Africa and APAC.

03

Fronts

01

Interchange

The problem. Downgrades from missing Level 2/3 data, wrong card-present flags, no AVS, late capture.

Our move. Sort the qualification report by reason code. Fix the biggest bucket first.

02

Scheme fees

The problem. Dozens of network fee lines per acquirer. Nobody checks them.

Our move. Map each line to its rule. Flag what you shouldn't pay.

03

FX

The problem. The markup hides inside the rate.

Our move. Quote it per corridor, per order. Then decide where it sits.

04

Acceptance

The problem. Declines and 3DS friction lose sales the cost report never shows.

Our move. Soft vs hard declines, smart retries, network tokens, account updater, 3DS exemptions. Price each lost sale against the fee.

05

Routing

The problem. Volume goes where it went last year.

Our move. Route on all-in cost per approved order. LCR on debit, tested failover, portable volume for leverage.

06

Cross-border

The problem. Local-eligible payments pay cross-border fees and FX twice.

Our move. One corridor: local acquiring or A2A vs a control, on cost, approvals and settlement days. Stablecoins, same scorecard.

04

How we work

  1. Margin Teardown

  2. Campaign Sprint

  3. Board sessions and workshops

  4. Retained advisory

See Advisory →

Route brief

Follow the money. Find the friction.

Pick a market and a method. See the rails, the rule-setters and what to ask.

Terrain, not relationships. Public sources only. Nothing you pick leaves this page.

United States · Bank transfer

US bank transfer

Updated 8 Nov 2026 · Linked rule context ↗
Payment instructionYour business
Recipient accountDomestic US

Routes to investigate

  • ACHUS bank rail: pay-ins and payouts, run under Nacha rules
  • RTPUS real-time payments network operated by The Clearing House
  • FedNowUS instant payments, operated by the Federal Reserve

Alternatives, not legs. Each prices differently; your provider decides eligibility.

Who sets the rules

  • NachaGoverns the ACH Network rules
  • Federal ReserveCentral bank; operates FedNow
  • CFPBConsumer financial protection regulator
  • FinCENAnti-money-laundering authority under the Bank Secrecy Act

Three checks before you move

  1. Where the fee becomes a lossProcessing cost vs returns, exceptions and ops effort.
  2. Who can use the routeEligibility, limits, access. A listing isn't approval.
  3. Who owns the exceptionSettlement, recon and recovery path, before you switch.

United States · Cards

US card acceptance

Card paymentYour checkout
AcquirerRouting decision

Routes to investigate

  • Debit routingReg II: two unaffiliated debit networks, merchant picks the route
  • Network tokensNetwork tokens and account updater on stored cards
  • Second acquirerAll-in cost per approved order, failover tested

Options, not advice. Issuers set which debit networks a card carries.

Who sets the rules

  • Federal ReserveCentral bank; sets Regulation II
  • EMVCoSets the EMV and EMV 3-D Secure specifications
  • PCI SSCSets the PCI DSS card-data security standard
  • CFPBConsumer financial protection regulator

Three checks before you move

  1. Which downgrades you pay forQualification report by reason code: L2/3 data, card-present, AVS, capture.
  2. Who chooses the debit routeIs your acquirer doing LCR, or defaulting?
  3. Which declines are softSoft vs hard. Price each lost sale against the fee.

Rule status, dated

3DS / SCA
EMVCo sets EMV 3DS. We cite no US rule that mandates SCA.

What we do not know

Your pricing model (blended or pass-through), downgrade volume, and how your acquirer routes debit today.

Sources

UK / EU · Cards

UK / EU card acceptance

Updated 8 Nov 2026 · Linked rule context ↗
Card paymentYour checkout
Issuer authentication3DS and SCA

Routes to investigate

  • 3DS exemptionsWhere approvals are won or lost under strong customer authentication
  • Bank debitEnabled market by market across the EU
  • Open bankingAccount-to-account payment, enabled market by market

Authentication decides conversion. Alternatives depend on the market and your provider.

Who sets the rules

  • EBAEU banking authority; PSD2 and SCA technical standards
  • FCAAuthorises payment and e-money institutions
  • PSRPayment Systems Regulator
  • EMVCoSets the EMV 3-D Secure specification
  • UK FinanceUK banking and finance trade association
  • European Payments CouncilManages the SEPA payment schemes

Three checks before you move

  1. Where friction costs the salePrice 3DS drop-off against the fee line.
  2. Which exemptions you useCheck which SCA exemptions your provider applies, and on which flows.
  3. Which market needs a local methodWhere bank debit or open banking beats a card.

Rule status, dated

3DS / SCA
EU: SCA under PSD2, with EBA technical standards. UK: SCA under FCA rules.
PSD3 / PSR (EU)
Not in force. Council adopted its first-reading position on 29 Oct 2026; Parliament's second reading is pending. PSD2 still applies.

Brazil · Instant / A2A

Brazil instant payment

Updated 8 Nov 2026 · Linked rule context ↗
Payment instructionCross-border seller
Local settlementBrazil

Routes to investigate

  • PixInstant payment scheme created by Banco Central do Brasil
  • Local acquiringLocal acquiring and local methods decide approval rates
  • Cross-border cardThe baseline to beat: cross-border fees and FX, sometimes twice

Test one corridor against a control before rolling anything out.

Who sets the rules

  • Banco Central do BrasilCentral bank and payments regulator
  • EMVCoSets the EMV specifications for the card baseline
  • PCI SSCSets the PCI DSS card-data security standard

Three checks before you move

  1. Where the FX markup sitsMarkup per corridor, per order. Then place it.
  2. Local or cross-borderCompare all-in cost, approval and settlement days against a held-out control.
  3. Who owns the entity questionCheck what local presence a local route needs before you price it.

Rule status, dated

3DS / SCA
Not yet sourced for Brazil.

What we do not know

Your entity setup, local acquiring access, where conversion happens, and settlement timing.

Sources

Australia & NZ · Cards

Australia & NZ card acceptance

Updated 8 Nov 2026 · Linked rule context ↗
Card paymentYour checkout
AcquirerDual-network debit

ExperienceAnitha set up Braintree Australia, twice.

Routes to investigate

  • Least-cost routingSend dual-network debit via the network that costs less. The RBA expects acquirers to offer and promote it.
  • eftposAustralia's domestic debit card scheme
  • Bank acquirersANZ, CBA, NAB and Westpac report LCR take-up to the RBA

Options to investigate. LCR can be binary, threshold or dynamic, and your provider sets which.

Who sets the rules

  • RBAPayments System Board; regulates designated card networks
  • AusPayNetIndustry body; runs the CNP Fraud Mitigation Framework
  • Commerce CommissionNZ; regulates Mastercard and Visa interchange under the Retail Payment System Act 2022
  • Payments NZGoverns the rules for NZ's core payment systems

Three checks before you move

  1. Is LCR on, and which kindCheck binary, threshold or dynamic routing, in person and online.
  2. Where the surcharge used to sitPrice the acceptance cost you can no longer pass on in Australia.
  3. Did the cut reach your feeCompare your rate with the pass-through large acquirers must publish from 30 Jan 2027.

Rule status, dated

AU surcharging
Removed from 1 Oct 2026 on eftpos, Mastercard and Visa.
AU interchange
Lower domestic caps from 1 Oct 2026; a cap on foreign-issued cards from 1 Apr 2027. Online and wallet LCR is under further RBA consultation.
NZ interchange
Personal-card limits from 1 Dec 2025 (domestic) and 1 May 2026 (foreign); commercial credit limits from 22 Apr 2027.
3DS / SCA
AU: AusPayNet requires SCA once a merchant breaches its fraud threshold for consecutive quarters. NZ: not yet sourced.

Australia & NZ · Instant / A2A

Australia instant payment

Payment instructionYour business
Customer bank accountAustralia

Routes to investigate

  • NPPAustralia's real-time payments platform
  • PayToBusiness-initiated real-time payments from a customer's bank account, under an agreement the customer authorises
  • Card baselineCompare against card cost after the Oct 2026 changes

Alternatives, not one route. Your bank or provider decides access.

Who sets the rules

  • Australian Payments PlusRuns NPP and PayTo
  • RBACentral bank; Payments System Board
  • AusPayNetAustralian Payments Network; industry body

Three checks before you move

  1. Which flows suit PayToList recurring and ad-hoc pulls now on cards or direct debit.
  2. Who can offer itAsk your bank or provider about PayTo access and pricing.
  3. Who owns the exceptionCheck agreement changes, failures and reconciliation before you move.

Rule status, dated

NZ instant / A2A
Not yet sourced.

What we do not know

Your bank or provider access, price, limits, and customer take-up.

Sources

Options to investigate, not confirmed availability or advice.

Bring us a margin problem

Terrain

The terrain your margin crosses

Listed as terrain, not as relationships.

01US

  1. ACHrail
  2. RTPrail
  3. FedNowrail
  4. CFPBregulator
  5. OCCregulator
  6. FDICregulator
  7. FinCENregulator
  8. Federal Reservecentral bank
  9. Nachascheme
  10. CFTCregulator

02UK / EU

  1. SEPArail
  2. FCAregulator
  3. PSRregulator
  4. EBAregulator
  5. ECBcentral bank
  6. European Payments Councilscheme
  7. BaFinregulator
  8. Banca d'Italiacentral bank
  9. UK Financeindustry body

03Canada & LATAM

  1. Payments Canadaoperator
  2. FINTRACregulator
  3. Banco Central do Brasilcentral bank
  4. Banxicocentral bank

04Africa

  1. SARBcentral bank
  2. PASAoperator

05APAC

  1. RBIcentral bank
  2. NPCIoperator

06Australia & NZ

  1. NPPrail
  2. PayTorail
  3. eftposscheme
  4. RBAcentral bank
  5. ASICregulator
  6. APRAregulator
  7. AUSTRACregulator
  8. AusPayNetindustry body
  9. Australian Payments Plusoperator
  10. Commerce Commissionregulator
  11. Payments NZindustry body
  12. ANZ · CBA · NAB · Westpacacquirers

07Global

  1. EMVCostandard
  2. PCI SSCstandard

Ways to work together

See Advisory →

The Briefing

One tactic a month. About 150 readers. Invite-only.

Working Sessions

8-12 peers, one lever, closed room, around major conferences.

Margin Teardown

Two days in your data. A ranked 90-day list, an owner each.

Advisory

Sprints on one decision, plus retained support while moves land.

How engagements run

  1. Scope. One call to name the number. A fixed fee, one deliverable.

  2. Clear the ground. Conflict check before anything confidential. Conflicts, we decline.

  3. Work quietly. NDA as standard. Client names only with written permission.

  4. Hand over. Ranked moves, an owner each, and the metric that proves it.

Start a conversation Ways to work together

Our network

Network

Networks, acquirers, banks, processors and wallets, plus the bodies that set the rules. We know how each prices and where it gives ground.

Plate IIIThe port

75 names and 10 markets in the network. Start a conversation or see Advisory.

Partners and platforms 75 names

Networks & rails 5 namesCard networks · ACH · RTP · +2 more

The rails underneath everything: scheme rules, network pricing and settlement.

  • Card networksNetwork pricing & partnerships
  • ACHUS bank rail: pay-ins & payouts
  • RTPUS real-time payments
  • FedNowUS instant payments
  • SEPAEuro bank rail; P1 incident command
Acquirers 11 namesFiserv · Deutsche Bank · Fifth Third Bank · +8 more

Who holds the merchant, and on what terms.

  • FiservAcquiring, processing & zero-copy data partner
  • Deutsche BankAcquiring partner
  • Fifth Third BankAcquiring partner
  • Merrick BankAcquiring partner
  • CieloAcquiring partner, Brazil
  • RedeAcquiring partner, Brazil
  • FISAcquiring partner
  • J.P. MorganAcquiring partner
  • MonerisAcquiring partner
  • AIBMSAcquiring partner
  • NABAcquiring partner, Australia
Sponsor & partner banks 6 namesMVB Bank · Pathward · Santander · +3 more

Who holds the money, the BIN and the licence.

  • MVB BankPartner bank
  • PathwardPartner bank
  • SantanderPartner bank
  • FNBRetail & business banking
  • Rand Merchant BankBank partner
  • FirstRand Bank IndiaBank partner, India
Processors & PSPs 6 namesBraintree · Stripe · Cardinal Commerce · +3 more

Gateways, 3DS servers and local-method routing.

  • BraintreeGateway and enterprise acquiring
  • StripeProcessor and platform payments
  • Cardinal Commerce3DS partner
  • Netcetera3DS partner
  • PProLocal payment methods
  • OmniPay
Wallets & platforms 10 namesPayPal · Venmo · Hyperwallet · +7 more

Wallets, payouts, BNPL, open banking and data.

  • PayPalEnterprise payments, pricing & FX
  • VenmoProcessing rails, onboarding to recon
  • HyperwalletPayouts & payout network connectivity
  • PayPal WorldCross-border wallet interoperability
  • VEONMobile wallets and e-money
  • KlarnaBNPL partner
  • AfterpayBNPL partner
  • GoCardlessBank debit partner
  • TinkOpen banking partner
  • SnowflakeZero-copy data platform
Merchants & verticals 7 namesRentoza · Effectus Capital Management · Travel, mobility, ticketing · +4 more

Named only where already public. Verticals stand in for clients.

  • RentozaCo-founded; consumer fintech
  • Effectus Capital ManagementCo-founded; licensed FSP
  • Travel, mobility, ticketingMarquee enterprise merchants
  • Digital-first & digital goodsEnterprise segments
  • Omni-channel & in-storeEnterprise segments
  • MarketplacesPayments and risk
  • High-risk verticalsMigration & expansion: real-money gaming, adult, nutraceuticals, prediction markets, CBD, alcohol delivery
Regulators & schemes 30 namesCFPB · OCC · FDIC · +27 more

The rule-setters in our markets: regulators, central banks and scheme bodies. Listed as terrain, not as relationships.

  • CFPBUSConsumer financial protection regulator
  • OCCUSCharters and supervises national banks
  • FDICUSDeposit insurer and bank supervisor
  • FinCENUSAnti-money-laundering authority under the Bank Secrecy Act
  • Federal ReserveUSCentral bank; operates FedNow and sets Regulation II
  • NachaUSGoverns the ACH Network rules
  • CFTCUSDerivatives regulator, including event contracts
  • FCAUKAuthorises payment and e-money institutions
  • PSRUKPayment Systems Regulator
  • EBAEUEU banking authority; PSD2 and SCA technical standards
  • ECBEUEuro-area central bank and payment-system overseer
  • European Payments CouncilEUManages the SEPA payment schemes
  • BaFinDEFederal financial supervisor
  • Banca d'ItaliaITCentral bank and payment-system overseer
  • Payments CanadaCAOperates national clearing and settlement systems
  • FINTRACCAFinancial intelligence unit and AML regulator
  • Banco Central do BrasilBRCentral bank and payments regulator
  • BanxicoMXCentral bank; operates SPEI
  • RBIINCentral bank and payments regulator
  • NPCIINOperates retail payment systems
  • RBAAUCentral bank; Payments System Board
  • ASICAUCorporate and financial services regulator
  • APRAAUPrudential regulator for banks
  • AUSTRACAUAML/CTF regulator and financial intelligence unit
  • AusPayNetAUAustralian Payments Network; industry self-regulatory body
  • eftposAUDomestic debit card scheme
  • SARBZACentral bank; oversees the national payment system
  • PASAZAPayments Association of South Africa; manages payment clearing under SARB oversight
  • EMVCoGlobalSets the EMV and EMV 3-D Secure specifications
  • PCI SSCGlobalSets the PCI DSS card-data security standard

Markets 10 markets

United States

Terrain: ACH, RTP, FedNow, push-to-card, wires. Each prices differently.

Canada

Terrain: Same cards, different rails. Price Canada as its own corridor.

Mexico, Brazil & LATAM

Terrain: Local acquiring decides approvals. Cielo and Rede in Brazil.

United Kingdom

Terrain: 3DS and SCA decide approvals.

European Union

Terrain: Local methods, bank debit, open banking, market by market.

Eurasia

Terrain: Wallets and e-money settle locally per operating company.

Italy

Terrain: Same group, different country, different settlement.

South Asia

Terrain: Real-time rails set the bar for card pricing.

Australia & APAC

Terrain: Local wallets and schemes decide if you can take payment. NAB in Australia.

South Africa & Africa

Terrain: Home ground. Mobile money and FX access decide settlement.

Client names appear only where already public. Views are our own.

12 tactics.No themes.

% FEE

Each one a move you can start Monday, in four markets.

Pick your front
  1. Agentic front

    Price the agent channel before it prices you

    Read the playNext: 02 NET IT OUTSame front: 04 REVERSE

    Tactic 1: Price the agent channel before it prices you

  2. Core · Platforms

    Report net revenue and take rate, not headline TPV

    Read the playNext: 03 SPREADSame front: 03 SPREADPlatforms: 04 REVERSE

    Tactic 2: Report net revenue and take rate, not headline TPV

  3. Core front

    Quote the FX markup per corridor, per order

    Read the playNext: 04 REVERSESame front: 05 BUY-SELL

    Tactic 3: Quote the FX markup per corridor, per order

  4. Agentic · Platforms

    Build the ledger for money flowing back to the agent

    Read the playNext: 05 BUY-SELLSame front: 07 MANDATEPlatforms: 05 BUY-SELL

    Tactic 4: Build the ledger for money flowing back to the agent

  5. Core · Platforms

    Choose agent or merchant of record flow by flow, and price the liability

    Read the playNext: 06 GO LOCALSame front: 06 GO LOCALPlatforms: 09 EMBED

    Tactic 5: Choose agent or merchant of record flow by flow, and price the liability

  6. Core front

    Move one corridor to local rails or account-to-account payments

    Read the playNext: 07 MANDATESame front: 08 RE-PRICE

    Tactic 6: Move one corridor to local rails or account-to-account payments

  7. Agentic front

    Bind every agent purchase to a user mandate

    Read the playNext: 08 RE-PRICESame front: 10 OPEN UP

    Tactic 7: Bind every agent purchase to a user mandate

  8. Core front

    Reprice enterprise deals on net margin, not volume

    Read the playNext: 09 EMBEDSame front: 09 EMBED

    Tactic 8: Reprice enterprise deals on net margin, not volume

  9. Core · Platforms

    Price PayFac and embedded payments on who carries the loss

    Read the playNext: 10 OPEN UPSame front: 11 AIR COVERPlatforms: 02 NET IT OUT

    Tactic 9: Price PayFac and embedded payments on who carries the loss

  10. Agentic front

    Make your checkout agent-ready on your own terms

    Read the playNext: 11 AIR COVERSame front: 01 PRICE IT

    Tactic 10: Make your checkout agent-ready on your own terms

  11. Core front

    Map licences, scheme rules and tax duties before a flow gets big

    Read the playNext: 12 SETTLESame front: 12 SETTLE

    Tactic 11: Map licences, scheme rules and tax duties before a flow gets big

  12. Core front

    Run stablecoin settlement on one corridor as a cost line, float included

    Read the playNext: 01 PRICE ITSame front: 02 NET IT OUT

    Tactic 12: Run stablecoin settlement on one corridor as a cost line, float included

Every tactic, the same way

  1. The move and how it works, step by step
  2. Prerequisites: contracts, data, systems, people
  3. Metrics and impact range, sourced or labelled as an assumption
  4. Failure modes, early warnings and rollback
  5. Owner: who decides, who builds, who watches the number
  6. Cross-continent campaign column: US, UK/EU, Africa, APAC

Where we've made the case

Snowflake Summit 2025, Money20/20 USA 2024, Fiserv Forum 2024 and MRC Las Vegas 2024. Speaking

Speaking

Play the games

Daily, Spot the Leak, Price the Deal, Pub Quiz, Season 1.

Play the games

Find the line item.

↑ ↓ move · Enter opens · Esc closes. My markets applies.